Reassessment Check or a property-tax appeal firm? An honest comparison
If your new Lycoming County value looks wrong to you, you have three broad routes: do it yourself with a kit like Reassessment Check, hire a firm that handles assessment appeals, or hire a Pennsylvania attorney. This page lays out what each one is good at, in plain terms, including where Reassessment Check is the weaker choice. We make Reassessment Check, so read this with that in mind, and check the facts yourself.
This page is general information. It is not legal advice and not an appraisal. You decide what to do.
The short version
| Reassessment Check | An appeal firm | A Pennsylvania attorney | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you get | Your deadline counted, the county's record checked against your measurements, tax arithmetic as a range, a printed packet of your own facts | A firm that gathers the evidence and handles the paperwork, on terms it sets | Legal advice and, if you hire one for it, someone who prepares and argues the appeal |
| Who decides whether to appeal | You | You, with the firm's input | You, with the attorney's advice |
| Who signs and files | You | Ask the firm who signs and who appears at a hearing | The attorney, when acting for you |
| Who gives a value opinion | Nobody. It is not an appraisal | Ask what the firm's opinion is based on | Usually relies on an appraiser or broker |
| Cost | $39 one time, planned. The deadline, tax and programs steps are free | Set by the firm. Ask for the terms in writing | Set by the attorney |
| Your data | Stays on your device | Shared with the firm | Shared with the attorney |
| Time you spend | A few evenings: measure, photograph, gather | Less | Less |
When a self-help kit fits
- Your first question is simply "what is the date, and what are the numbers?" The informal review with the county's contractor is free, and in Lycoming County the formal appeal fee is waived during this reassessment. Many owners only need to be organised for those two steps.
- You think the county's record of your house is wrong (living area, basement finish, baths, outbuildings) and you can check that with a tape measure and photos.
- You want to see the tax arithmetic before you decide anything: a higher value does not always mean a higher bill, because the rates are reset too.
- You want to keep your data private and your decision your own.
When a firm or an attorney fits better
- You want someone to argue it for you. Reassessment Check does not prepare an appeal and does not appear at a hearing. In Pennsylvania only a licensed attorney may prepare or argue an appeal for someone else, according to the Pennsylvania Bar Association's unauthorized-practice opinions, so if a firm offers to do this, ask who is the attorney.
- The property is complicated. Commercial, rental, farm and mixed-use properties, income-based valuation, and unusual buildings are beyond a homeowner kit.
- You want a professional value opinion. The kit points to who gives one (a Pennsylvania-certified appraiser or a licensed broker). It does not give one.
- You are short of time or confident in someone else's judgment. Handing it off is a fair choice.
If you are thinking about hiring a firm, ask
- Who exactly will sign the appeal form, and who will attend the hearing for me? Are they a Pennsylvania-licensed attorney?
- How are you paid: a flat fee, a share of any reduction, or something else? What do I owe if nothing changes? Is the agreement in writing?
- Will I owe anything if the value goes up after review?
- What will you do that I cannot do myself for free at the informal review?
- What evidence do you plan to use, and do I see it before it is filed?
- What happens to my documents and photos, and who sees my information?
- Is the 40-day window counted from my notice's mailing date already covered, and who is watching it?
Nothing here says a firm is a bad choice. Some owners are well served by one. The point is to compare like with like and to know what you are paying for.
How Reassessment Check works with either route
Because the packet is only your own facts (your measurements, dated photos, your purchase information, your list of sales you picked), you can use it on your own, or hand it to an attorney, appraiser or firm so they start from your records. It leaves the "basis" box on the county's form blank for whoever signs the form. It never tells you whether to appeal and never fills in or files county forms.
Price: the deadline counter and tax arithmetic are free; the full kit is planned at $39, one time. Not live yet.
Sources
- Lycoming County Assessment Office: reassessment FAQ (appeal fee waived during the reassessment) and Important Dates page (40 days from the date mailed).
- Tyler Technologies, Lycoming County reassessment FAQ brochure (informal review after the value change notices, formal appeal hearing afterward).
- Pennsylvania Bar Association Unauthorized Practice of Law Committee, Opinion 98-101; Westmoreland County v. RTA Group.